Cass withdraws support for draft conversion practices bill
Baroness Cass, author of the review of NHS gender services for children, told a parliamentary committee she does not support the draft bill banning conversion practices, having welcomed it in June. A ban is “desirable”, she told the Today programme, but “we have not yet as far as I can see got a workable bill”. She warned of a “chilling effect” on therapists and of risks to parents. The Government said it wants “to get this ban right”.
The draft requires that a victim suffer serious harm or serious alarm or distress; Lady Cass fears “vexatious” complaints against clinicians treating gender-distressed young people. “It is the process which ends up being an unwarranted punishment,” she said. A parent withholding money for a breast binder or hormones might also fall within scope. She said she had not read the detail before supplying a supportive quotation in June. The bill, which applies to England and Wales and carries up to five years in prison, is in pre-legislative scrutiny before a joint committee. Stonewall and the British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy support it. “We want a legal ban,” said Dr Igi Moon, for a coalition of more than 25 organisations.